Cruise Shore Excursion Accident Sparks Legal and Safety Concerns

The recent accident involving Hannah Smith, a 22-year-old graduate, during a shore excursion in Nassau, Bahamas, booked through Carnival Cruise Line, has brought to light the pressing issues of passenger safety and the legal responsibilities of cruise lines. On May 12, 2025, Smith suffered life-altering injuries after being drawn into the propellers of a catamaran operated by Pearl Investment Management Group, Ltd. and Sun Cay Ltd., leading to the amputation of both legs.

Brais Law Firm, specializing in cruise ship shore excursion accidents, is representing Smith in a pre-suit investigation. Preliminary findings suggest potential lawsuits against Carnival Corporation and the excursion operators for negligence and unsafe practices. Carnival is expected to argue that the excursion operators are independent contractors, thereby limiting their liability.

This incident underscores the broader implications for the cruise industry, particularly concerning the safety standards of third-party excursions promoted by cruise lines. The outcome of this case could set a precedent for how cruise lines are held accountable for the safety of their passengers during shore excursions. Meanwhile, Smith's family has started a GoFundMe Campaign to assist with her medical and rehabilitation expenses.